Comments on: TEN GARDENING TIPS I WILL NEVER WRITE ABOUT https://gardern.co.za/2015/03/ten-gardening-tips-i-will-never-write/ Horticulturist Matt Mattus shares gardening expertise, research and science from his home garden and greenhouse. Mon, 08 Feb 2021 21:20:43 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.1 By: admin Matt https://gardern.co.za/2015/03/ten-gardening-tips-i-will-never-write/#comment-5309 Mon, 08 Feb 2021 21:20:43 +0000 #comment-5309 In reply to Amanda.

I know and I’m so sorry about that. I hate to blame my publisher, but it’s true (which is why I am not posting this). I was mortified when I noticed that they never made any of my corrections, and then seemed to make even more mistakes. They even spelled my name wrong on the inside cover! I’ll never publish with them again. I hope that you can look beyond the errors and typos. At least they made some of the changes to a few of the captions that were wrong on every draft (mimulus instead of cosmos) yet others remained un-corrected (Primula japonica, and a list too long for me to include here). I really don’t know what to do, but it’s one reason why I am not promoting the book that intensely right now.

]]>
By: Amanda https://gardern.co.za/2015/03/ten-gardening-tips-i-will-never-write/#comment-5305 Thu, 28 Jan 2021 05:08:42 +0000 #comment-5305 In reply to Matt Mattus.

Well actually, I had to put your book Mastering the Art of Flower Gardening down since it is also riddled with mistakes. Did no one edit this book? There is a mistake in the introduction. Wow.

]]>
By: Matt Mattus https://gardern.co.za/2015/03/ten-gardening-tips-i-will-never-write/#comment-1337 Sun, 29 Mar 2015 01:15:12 +0000 #comment-1337 In reply to Jonathan Stone.

Don't make me pull out my dictionary, Jonathan! You are correct of course when it comes to the many specialized plant societies. I wonder if this current interest in gardening will evolve in some people who will graduate and move on to search for a deeper experience from gardening and plant life. I hope so! Thanks.

]]>
By: Jonathan Stone https://gardern.co.za/2015/03/ten-gardening-tips-i-will-never-write/#comment-1336 Sat, 28 Mar 2015 17:53:23 +0000 #comment-1336 Nice pryterritzyoh, Matt, I wouldn't write about them either. The antidote to helpful hints which might not work, is the specialized plant societies which match your interest, in which are found generous gardeners who will know the answers to your questions and be willing to talk plants with you. They are also the source for finding what are the best, most enlightening, entertaining and valuable books, as well as the source for otherwise unobtainable seed. A young gardener would be well-served to join the group which would welcome him, and understand him.

]]>
By: Matt Mattus https://gardern.co.za/2015/03/ten-gardening-tips-i-will-never-write/#comment-1335 Fri, 27 Mar 2015 21:35:20 +0000 #comment-1335 In reply to Erin @ The Impatient Gardener.

Thanks, Erin. I was just thinking ( as, once I rant, I start to back pedal!), that it might be interesting to write a post asking everyone to look back in their life, and share what first inspired them to garden, and then what did they actually grow? I first grew either sunflower seeds in one of my mothers impatiens that she brought in for the winter, or a grapefruit tree from a seed which I kept until I was in college – things we might poo poo now, but from the perspective of a child, or a young adult who is just learning how to garden – not so. I wonder then if we are on the cusp of an enormous growth in gardening – as even some of my friends who are in their 30's – first-time gardeners 5 years ago, have quickly moved on to more interesting plants, because they are now hooked. Maybe – Pinterest and DIY posts are not so silly after all? What is the first thing one does when faced with a plant they do not know? They search for more information about it – on-line. In a very real way, it may not be the same thing as tramping through the woods looking to discover, but it is still an exploration. Maybe kids today and adults who are new to gardening are just starting this journey?

]]>
By: Erin @ The Impatient Gardener https://gardern.co.za/2015/03/ten-gardening-tips-i-will-never-write/#comment-1334 Fri, 27 Mar 2015 19:55:49 +0000 #comment-1334 I feel the same way you do on many of the topics you discuss. It's honestly why I've really cooled on Pinterest; because it is aggravating to have to wade through pin after pin about "Plant your breakfast (eggs, coffee and bananas) with your roses," or the latest pin from what I can only assume is a very well-funded and active Epsom salt lobby (how is it possible that you can find pins right next to each other that claim that Epsom salt will give you the best tomatoes you've ever had and also dissolve old tree trunks?) or something that tells me to put a diaper in the bottom of my containers.

It is frustrating but at the same time I have difficulty poo-pooing anything that might pique a potential gardener's interest. If you can plant the seed (to use an overly obvious metaphor), perhaps they'll grow as gardeners and as they do they'll find expert gardening blogs. Just the other day I wrote a post about how, as a new homeowner and novice gardener, I ignored advice to pull Campanula rapunculoides from my garden. "It's pretty," I said. More than a decade later, I continue to pay the price for ignoring that advice. But since then I've become a master gardener, spend more on gardening-related pursuits than any other discretionary spending item, get my soil tested and research plants before I buy them and learned that the plant with the pretty purple flowers is called Campanula rapunculoides and it's a labeled invasive in our area.

Should we teach kids the right way from the beginning? You bet. But if someone happens upon gardening because they found out on Pinterest that loofahs are really gourds, I'll just hope that someday they also learn that Epsom salt only works if you have a magnesium deficiency.

]]>
By: Jean Campbell https://gardern.co.za/2015/03/ten-gardening-tips-i-will-never-write/#comment-1333 Fri, 27 Mar 2015 05:01:23 +0000 #comment-1333 This comment has been removed by the author.

]]>
By: Matt Mattus https://gardern.co.za/2015/03/ten-gardening-tips-i-will-never-write/#comment-1332 Fri, 27 Mar 2015 04:10:44 +0000 #comment-1332 In reply to rochelle at PITH + VIGOR.

Rochelle – What an interesting point – I never thought about looking at this from the other perspective? Ranting is such an odd thing anyway, since what I vent and write one day, I often wince at reading on the third! But it is what it is, and as we have mashed over pizza and Afgahni food more than once – all part of this social media transparent blogging thing anyway! Especially with us creative types. Hell, even a bad color combination can sometime tip me over the edge, but only until I consider it from a different perspective. Thanks for sharing and smacking me in the head about this one! One note though ( or two) about what some may consider impractical – I think sometimes 'impractical' could be raising something which requires great knowledge or experience, or assembling an important collection which even I sometimes receive comments about as being excessive or un-realistic – I think we have to factor in talent and skill, along with the more subjective views like 'taste' and 'class'. Of course, nothing is truly 'right' or 'wrong' when it comes to managing Mother Nature – we can only offer our opinions. In the end, what makes ones skin 'crawl' may give someone goosebumps. Opinion is a lovely, horrible thing.

]]>
By: Matt https://gardern.co.za/2015/03/ten-gardening-tips-i-will-never-write/#comment-1331 Fri, 27 Mar 2015 03:31:42 +0000 #comment-1331 Great list, funny and so true about marigolds. Not so funny that mine were infested with aphids last year, so what do those believers have to say about them keeping aphids away now?

]]>
By: rochelle at PITH + VIGOR https://gardern.co.za/2015/03/ten-gardening-tips-i-will-never-write/#comment-1330 Fri, 27 Mar 2015 00:40:26 +0000 #comment-1330 I love it when friends rant (it makes me feel a little less out of line when I launch in to my own tirades) ;). I have to say I do agree with CL though (slight ambivalence about all the crafty/pinteresty things). I think it is important to remember that eye candy, whether in the form of dippy wine crate planters or in the form of highly manicured, extremely expensive, impractical, must-have-hired-help, high-end editorial gardens are equally dishonest – as well as equally inspiring. One is however attainable to the masses and might get someone trying somthing out (albeit probably quickly failing) where as the other does make for a nice photo shot but often does little more than breed hopeless classism. I think the problem is that we hardly ever really criticize the monied gardens (why?) but we readily shake our heads in disgust at the silliness of the cheap and cheerful (I'm guilty of it myself). Do I like impractical stupid garden craft – NO – makes my skin crawl — but I do see a positive side. But if we are to add this to a list of things we don't want to write about – I think 'we' ('cause we do this together, right?) should also add to the list any sort of over glorification of those countless 'pretty but impractical', or the 'its beautiful only because it is expensive', and those 'this doesn't exist without a shameful amount of chemicals' types of gardens too. – P.s. I also just realized your sidebar link to my site is broken… and excuse me if this came through 2x – it blanked out on me and I don't know if went through the 1st time.

]]>